9.8 REVISED ONE BITE RANKING Review by Dave Portnoy
Let’s get the iconic pizza back!
Santillo's is one of the most iconic pizzerias not only in America but the world. It's been in the Santillo family since 1918. Santillo's burned down in a fire on January 6th. He didn't have fire insurance because he couldn't get it because of his iconic oven. It's time to support one of the true icons in the pizza game and a legendary small business. All funds from his subscriptions will go directly to Al to rebuilding Santillo's.
Best in the world - Was in NYC from Ireland, rented a car just to drive to NJ to try it - Exceeded my expectations - Got the 1957 with half sesame seed crust - Al Santillo is a gentlemen.
This is a made man throwing the pies here! Best in the NY & NJ and we claim the real Italian's outside of Italy! You will not find this pizza anywhere else!
Pizza perfection. Hours restrict how often someone can frequent this establishment during the week but I've never had any issues picking up deliciously crispy pizza whenever I've craved it. A true North Jersey pizza staple.
Enjoy Fresh Pizza Monthly
Subscribe now and get Al’s iconic 12" Cheese Pizza or 12" Pepperoni Pizza for pickup or delivery, every month for a year with our PizzaPass Subscription!
Subscribe nowCustomize Your Monthly Order
Want more? You can add extra toppings, upsize your pizza, or order any other homemade food item at menu price.
About Santillo’s
The Santillo’s Brick Oven Pizza journey started with Lou Santillo in 1918, He delivered bread via horse and buggy. By 1944 Lou and his son Alfred were making pizza in addition to Italian Bread. Currently, Lou Santillo’s Grandson, Al & Wife Lorraine operate Santillo’s Brick Oven Pizza.
Subscribe nowAbout Our Pizza
At Santillo’s Brick Oven Pizza, we ensure that we only serve pizza the way Italian traditions have taught us. From handing the dough and putting them into boxes to picking out unburned coal and poking the fire, we make sure to stick to the recipe we’ve developed.
Support Local Business
Inflation has hurt small businesses much more than large corporations. By purchasing a PizzaPass from us, you’re are supporting local business. When sharing a pizza, everyone is La Famiglia!
Questions?
What is a PizzaPass?
PizzaPass is a prepaid membership program designed to enjoy our iconic pizzas and save. With our PizzaPass program, you pay once and get a 12" Cheese Pizza or 12" Pepperoni Pizza every month.
Choose your plan:
$187 - one year (12 pizzas)
How much will I save?
- Save $53 with the annual plan
When is the last day to subscribe?
You can subscribe to our PizzaPass until October 01. Act fast and don’t miss out!
Is delivery available?
Yes! Delivery is available via DoorDash drivers for an added fee. Pickup is free.
Where can I purchase a PizzaPass subscription?
Our PizzaPass is only available on this website. Don’t miss out—quantities are limited.
When does my PizzaPass subscription start, and how does it work?
PizzaPass subscription start date is on Oct. 01, 2025. The activation code will be sent directly to your email monthly, until your PizzaPass expires.
What if I skip a week?
Unused codes don’t carry over. Please use it before it expires.
Can I buy more than one?
Unfortunately, no. It is currently limited to one membership per loyal customer.
Are there any restrictions?
No restrictions, but during peak times we may pause online orders briefly to ensure all our loyal customers, like you, are happy. We recommend ordering early!
What’s your refund policy?
Refunds are available within the first 30 days, when fewer than 4 pizzas are redeemed. Refunds are prorated at the original menu price of the redeemed pizzas and subject to a 3.5% payment processing fee.
CONTACT US
639 S Broad St, Elizabeth, NJ 07202, USA
(908) 354-1887
Santillo's Brick Oven Pizza
Order Online | Pickup, Delivery
Powered by
We’ll be live
on November 28! 🎉
Please check back soon.
