Tastier than Netflix? See why pizza subscriptions are a hit!
About Us
We’re in a league of our own when it comes to old-school New York-style pizza. Since 2004, our seasoned pizza makers have been serving handmade favorites using authentic, time-tested recipes. With pizzas, pastas, wings, and salads, there’s something for everyone at I Love NY Pizza Milton
The perfect spot to enjoy delicious pizza with friends. Backed by years in the restaurant business, we're known for our amazing pizza, wings, calzones, strombolis, salads, and pasta—all made by skilled chefs and a dedicated team.
Brings back happy pizza memories. I will be a regular A steady line of customers means it's a good, and popular restaurant.
Pizza's are absolutely delicious. I order the XL White with extra ricotta, extra cheese. Definitely the best place around. Friendly staff,
Best pizza in Henry County! Classic NY pizza with an array of other italian options. I refuse to get pizza from anywhere else in the area!
Enjoy Fresh Pizza Weekly
Subscribe now and get a Cheese Pizza or Pepperoni Pizza for pickup or delivery every week for one year or for 6 months with our PizzaPass!
Subscribe nowCustomize Your Weekly Order
Want more? You can add extra toppings, upsize your pizza, or order any other homemade food item at menu price.
Save Big on Pizza
You save $280 by subscribing to our PizzaPass, securing a delicious pizza every week without breaking the bank ($5.73 each).
Subscribe nowSupport Local Business
Inflation has hurt small businesses much more than large corporations. By purchasing a PizzaPass from us, you’re supporting local business.
When sharing a pizza, everyone is La Famiglia!
Questions?
What is a PizzaPass?
PizzaPass is a prepaid membership program designed to enjoy our iconic pizzas and save. With our PizzaPass program, you pay once and get a Cheese Pizza or Pepperoni Pizza every week.
Choose your plan:
$149 - 6 months (26 pizzas)
$197 - one year (52 pizzas)
How much will I save?
- Save $280 with the 6-month plan
- Save $661 with the annual plan
When is the last day to subscribe?
You can subscribe to our PizzaPass until July 16. Act fast and don’t miss out!
Is delivery available?
Yes! Delivery is available via DoorDash drivers for an added fee. Pickup is free.
Where can I purchase a PizzaPass subscription?
Our PizzaPass is only available on this website. Don’t miss out—quantities are limited.
When does my PizzaPass subscription start, and how does it work?
Your subscription begins right after purchase. You’ll receive a redemption code through the PizzaPass app, valid for a week. A new code will be sent every week, on Monday, until your plan ends.
What if I skip a week?
Unused codes don’t carry over. Please use it before it expires.
Can I buy more than one?
Unfortunately, no. It is currently limited to one membership per loyal customer.
Are there any restrictions?
No restrictions, but during peak times we may pause online orders briefly to ensure all our loyal customers, like you, are happy. We recommend ordering early!
What’s your refund policy?
Refunds are available within the first 30 days, when fewer than 4 pizzas are redeemed. Refunds are prorated at the original menu price of the redeemed pizzas and subject to a 3.5% payment processing fee.
CONTACT US
980 Birmingham Rd ste 200, Alpharetta, GA 30004, USA
(770) 442-9699
OPENING DAILY: 10:30 AM to 09:00 PM
We’ll be live
on June 15! 🎉
Please check back soon.
